The bench-scale test widely used to evaluate whether a burning cigarette will
ignite(点燃) upholstered furniture may underestimate the tendency of
component1 materials to
smolder2 when these materials are used in sofas and chairs supported by springs or cloth, National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) and American University researchers report in a new study. The study comes as regulations and methods for evaluating the likelihood that soft-furniture materials will ignite are undergoing
scrutiny3. In November 2013, California removed an open-flame test from its furniture flammability testing law**-the de facto national standard since no national regulation currently exists-and now relies
solely4 on the so-called cigarette-
smoldering5-ignition test.
The new research identifies changes to this test that might make it more realistic-representative of a "near-worst-case
scenario6." The
modifications7, the researchers write, would make the test more consistent and, therefore, more useful for identifying "
upholstery materials(室内装潢材料) most likely to prevent smoldering ignition."
In the same article, the research team reports guidelines for making a reproducible reference
foam8 for furniture flammability testing-a challenging, longstanding priority of standards developers, regulators and fire researchers. Such a
standardized9 foam would help in comparing flammability data from different laboratories.
In the current setup for the test, two
fabric10-covered foam pieces are positioned like seat and back cushions on a small solid wood support structure. A lit standard reference cigarette (one
certified11 by NIST to burn consistently***) is placed in the
crevice12 formed by the two pieces. To pass, a fabric covering or barrier material under test must prevent the burning cigarette from igniting the
underlying13 foam so that it does not smolder on its own, even after the cigarette self-extinguishes.
The researchers found that directly placing the test samples on top of the wooden support
impedes14 air flow and, as a consequence,
inhibits15 smoldering. They point out that the arrangement is not representative of furniture with cushions that rest on air-permeable substrates such as springs or cloth, which allows air to circulate and promotes smoldering.
The team introduced gaps between the foam samples and the underlying wood, permitting air flow. The adjustment increased-by up to threefold-the rate at which smoldering spread in the foam. It also generated significantly higher smoldering temperatures in the foam-as much as 400 degrees
Celsius16 higher.
"Because it inhibits air flow, the current test
apparatus17 may diminish the
propensity18 for smoldering ignition," explains NIST's Rick Davis. "Creating gaps to increase air flow, and the other modifications we are suggesting-especially
adoption19 of a reference foam-will enable more consistent smoldering behavior and help to minimize other causes of inconsistent flammability test results."