Despite a well-documented history of dramatic
genetic2 decay, the human Y
chromosome3 has over the course of millions of years of evolution managed to preserve a small set of
genes4 that has ensured not only its own survival but also the survival of men. Moreover, the vast majority of these
tenacious5(顽强的) genes appear to have little if any role in sex determination or
sperm6 production. Taken together, these
remarkable7 findings -- published this week in the journal Nature -- suggest that because these Y-linked genes are active across the body, they may actually be contributing to differences in disease susceptibility and severity observed between men and women.
"This paper tells us that not only is the Y chromosome here to stay, but that we need to take it seriously, and not just in the reproductive tract," says Whitehead Institute Director David Page, whose lab conducted the research with collaborators from Washington University in St. Louis and Baylor College of Medicine.
"There are approximately a dozen genes
conserved8 on the Y that are expressed in cells and tissue types throughout the body," he continues. "These are genes involved in
decoding9 and interpreting the entirety of the genome. How
pervasive10 their effects are is a question we throw open to the field, and it's one we can no longer ignore."
Page believes this research will at last allow his lab to transition from proving the so-called rotting Y theorists wrong to a new era in Y chromosome biology. Over the past decade, Page, who is also a professor of biology at MIT and an
investigator11 of the Howard Hughes Medical Institute, and his group have been
debunking12 the thinly supported but wildly popular argument that because the Y chromosome had lost hundreds of its genes over roughly 300 million years of evolution, its ultimate
extinction13 is
inevitable14.
The loss of genetic content on the Y is not in dispute. In fact, a recent study from Page's own lab showed that the human Y chromosome retains only 19 of the more than 600 genes it once shared with its ancestral autosomal partner, the X chromosome. However, by comparing the sequence of the human Y chromosome with that of the chimpanzee and the rhesus macaque, the lab discovered that the human Y has lost only one ancestral
gene1 over the past 25 million years. Since then, the Y has been more than holding its own.
Having shown that the human,
chimp15, and rhesus Y
chromosomes16 share nearly identical ancestral gene content, the lab set out in this latest work to map the evolution of the Y chromosomes of five more distantly-related mammals: the marmoset, mouse, rat, bull, and opossum. A comparison of the ancestral portions of these Y chromosomes revealed a set of broadly expressed genes across all eight species. Such genetic stability and conservation is no accident.
This is not just a
random17 sampling of the Y's ancestral repertoire," says Page, noting that each of the conserved genes discovered has a counterpart on the X chromosome. "This is an
elite18 bunch of genes."
"Evolution is telling us these genes are really important for survival," adds Winston Bellott, a research scientist in the Page lab and lead author of the Nature paper. "They've been selected and purified over time."