The first dengue
vaccine1 candidate (CYD-TDV) to reach phase 3 clinical testing has shown moderate protection (56%) against the disease in Asian children, according to new research published in The Lancet. Dengue is a mosquito-borne disease that infects around 390 million people each year, of whom about 96 million suffer from symptomatic infection. WHO estimates that the global burden of dengue has risen 30-fold over the past 50 years, with over half of the world's population at risk of the disease.
There is no
licensed2 vaccine available to treat or prevent dengue fever, and efforts to develop one have been complicated by the fact that dengue is caused by four distinct dengue viruses, and a vaccine must target all four serotypes (DENV 1-4).
This phase 3 trial took place in dengue-endemic areas across five countries in Asia, a region that accounts for over 70% of the global dengue burden. The study involved 10 275 healthy children
aged3 2 to 14 years who were
randomly4 assigned to receive three injections of the CYD-TDV vaccine (6851) or a
placebo5 (3424) at 0, 6, and 12 months, and followed for up to 2 years.
The researchers recorded 250 dengue cases more than 28 days after the third injection -- 117 in the vaccine group and 133 in the placebo group, demonstrating an overall protective efficacy of 56.5%.
The vaccine also showed 88.5% efficacy(功效) after 3 doses against severe disease (dengue haemorrhagic fever) which leads to hospitalisation for over half a million people (mostly children) every year, and 67% against dengue-associated hospitalisation.
The researchers found that the vaccine gave low protection (35%) against DENV 2, but more than 75% protection against DENV 3 and 4, and 50% against DENV 1.
The vaccine was generally well tolerated. A total of 647 serious
adverse6 events were reported, 402 (62%) in the vaccine group and 245 (38%) in the placebo group.
According to lead author Dr Maria Rosario Capeding from the Research Institute for Tropical Medicine in the Philippines, "Our results suggest that
vaccination7 with CYD-TDV can reduce the incidence of symptomatic dengue infection by more than half and importantly reduced severe disease and hospitalisations. This candidate vaccine has the potential to have a significant impact on public health in view of the high disease burden in endemic countries."
Writing in a linked Comment, Professor Annelies Wilder-Smith from Lee Kong Chian School of Medicine, Nanyang
Technological8 University, Singapore says, "Perhaps the most interesting finding of this trial was that efficacy after at least one dose was almost as high as that after three doses…Because three doses 6 months apart is an
inconvenient9 and
costly10 immunisation schedule for scale up in national programmes, the question of whether sufficient efficacy can be achieved with a lower number of doses deserves further
assessment11."
She adds, "With an estimated 96 million clinically apparent dengue infections
annually12, a reduction by half would present a significant public health benefit that would support dengue vaccine introduction….Whether the armamentarium of alternative vaccine candidates presently in the
pipeline13 (including
inactivated14, live
attenuated15,
chimeric16, recombinant, subunit and
DNA17 vaccines) will improve efficacy beyond 56%
remains18 to be established. For the moment, the CYD-TDV vaccine is the best we have; however, with 56% efficacy it will never be a single solution. Continued support for the development of other novel strategies including drugs, improved case management, insecticides, and new approaches to
vector(矢量,带菌者) control, is needed before effective dengue control becomes a
credible19 prospect20.