Decades of experiments have verified the
quirky(古怪的) laws of quantum theory again and again. So when scientists in Germany announced in 2012 an apparent
violation1 of a fundamental law of quantum mechanics, a
physicist2 at the University of Rochester was
determined3 to find an explanation. "You don't destroy the laws of quantum mechanics that easily," said Robert Boyd, professor of optics and of physics at Rochester and the Canada
Excellence4 Research Chair in Quantum Nonlinear Optics at the University of Ottawa.
In their 2012 version of the famous Young two-split experiment, Ralf Menzel and his colleagues at the University of Potsdam
simultaneously5 determined a photon's path and observed high contrast interference fringes created by the interaction of waves from the two
slits7.
"This result was extremely surprising, as one of the basic tenets of quantum mechanics holds that there should be no quantum interference when it is known through which
slit6 the particle (a photon in this case) had passed," said Boyd.
Inspired by these
intriguing8(有趣的) results, Boyd and his colleagues
replicated9 the Menzel experiment. Their findings were recently published online in an early edition of the
Proceedings10 of the National Academy of Sciences.
"The data of the Menzel experiment were very clean, so we weren't surprised to obtain the same initial result," said Boyd. "My coworkers and I asked what could explain this apparent violation of a key principle of quantum mechanics. What we found is that the resolution of the problem requires great subtly in the way that one needs to
analyze11 the data for this type of measurement."