The central mystery of quantum mechanics is that small
chunks1 of matter sometimes seem to behave like particles, sometimes like waves. For most of the past century, the
prevailing2 explanation of this
conundrum3 has been what's called the "Copenhagen
interpretation4" -- which holds that, in some sense, a single particle really is a wave,
smeared5 out across the universe, that
collapses6 into a determinate location only when observed. But some
founders7 of quantum physics --
notably8 Louis de Broglie -- championed an alternative interpretation, known as "pilot-wave theory," which
posits9 that quantum particles are borne along on some type of wave. According to pilot-wave theory, the particles have definite
trajectories10, but because of the pilot wave's influence, they still exhibit wavelike statistics.
John Bush, a professor of
applied11 mathematics at MIT, believes that pilot-wave theory deserves a second look. That's because Yves Couder, Emmanuel Fort, and colleagues at the University of Paris Diderot have recently discovered a macroscopic pilot-wave system whose
statistical12 behavior, in certain circumstances, recalls that of quantum systems.
Couder and Fort's system consists of a bath of fluid vibrating at a rate just below the threshold at which waves would start to form on its surface. A
droplet13 of the same fluid is released above the bath; where it strikes the surface, it causes waves to radiate outward. The droplet then begins moving across the bath, propelled by the very waves it creates.
"This system is
undoubtedly14 quantitatively15 different from quantum mechanics," Bush says. "It's also
qualitatively16 different: There are some features of quantum mechanics that we can't capture, some features of this system that we know aren't present in quantum mechanics. But are they
philosophically17 distinct?"