The analysis of artifacts from a 325,000-year-old site in Armenia shows that human
technological1 innovation occurred
intermittently2 throughout the Old World, rather than spreading from a single point of origin, as
previously3 thought. The study, published today in the journal Science, examines thousands of stone artifacts
retrieved4 from Nor Geghi 1, a unique site preserved between two
lava5 flows dated to 200,000-400,000 years ago. Layers of floodplain
sediments6 and an ancient soil found between these lava flows contain the archaeological material. The dating of
volcanic7 ash found within the sediments and
detailed8 study of the sediments themselves allowed researchers to correlate the stone tools with a period between 325,000 and 335,000 years ago when Earth's climate was similar to today's.
The stone tools provide early evidence for the simultaneous use of two distinct technologies: biface technology, commonly associated with hand
axe9 production during the Lower Paleolithic, and Levallois technology, a stone tool production method typically attributed to the Middle Stone Age in Africa and the Middle Paleolithic in Eurasia. Traditionally, Archaeologists use the development of Levallois technology and the
disappearance10 of biface technology to mark the transition from the Lower to the Middle Paleolithic roughly 300,000 years ago.
Archaeologists have argued that Levallois technology was invented in Africa and spread to Eurasia with expanding human populations, replacing local biface technologies in the process. This theory draws a link between populations and technologies and thus
equates11 technological change with demographic change. The co-existence of the two technologies at Nor Geghi 1 provides the first clear evidence that local populations developed Levallois technology out of existing biface technology.
"The combination of these different technologies in one place suggests to us that, about 325,000 years ago, people at the site were innovative," says Daniel Adler, associate professor of
Anthropology12 at the University of Connecticut, and the study's lead author. Moreover, the chemical analysis of several hundred
obsidian13 artifacts shows that humans at the site
utilized14 obsidian outcrops from as far away as 120 kilometers (approximately 75 miles), suggesting they must also have been capable of exploiting large, environmentally diverse territories.
The paper argues that biface and Levallois technology, while distinct in many regards, share a common pedigree. In biface technology, a mass of stone is shaped through the removal of
flakes15 from two surfaces in order to produce a tool such as a hand axe. The flakes detached during the manufacture of a biface are treated as waste. In Levallois technology, a mass of stone is shaped through the removal of flakes in order to produce a convex surface from which flakes of predetermined size and shape are detached. The predetermined flakes produced through Levallois technology are the desired products. Archaeologists suggest that Levallois t echnology is
optimal16 in terms of raw material use and that the predetermined flakes are
relatively17 small and easy to carry. These were important issues for the highly mobile hunter-gatherers of the time.