The
monarch1 butterfly is one of the most iconic insects in the world, best known for its distinct orange and black wings and a spectacular annual mass
migration2 across North America. However, little has been known about the
genes4 that
underlie5 these famous traits, even as the insect's storied migration appears to be in
peril6. Sequencing the genomes of monarch butterflies from around the world, a team of scientists has now made surprising new insights into the monarch's genetics. They identified a single
gene3 that appears central to migration -- a behavior generally regarded as complex -- and another that controls pigmentation. The researchers also shed light on the
evolutionary8 origins of the monarch. They report their findings Oct. 1 in Nature.
"The results of this study shift our whole thinking about these butterflies," said study senior author Marcus Kronforst, PhD, Neubauer Family Assistant Professor of Ecology and Evolution at the University of Chicago.
Every year, millions of
monarchs9 fly from as far north as Canada to spend the winter in Mexico. Predominantly a North American species, the monarch also exists in South and Central America, and has
relatively10 recently spread across the Atlantic and Pacific oceans. Only North American monarchs migrate.
A North American Original
To better understand monarch genetics and the basis for
migratory11 behavior, Kronforst's team sequenced and compared the genomes of 101 butterflies, including migratory North American monarchs, non-migratory monarchs from around the world and a few closely related species.
The researchers
analyzed12 the monarch's evolutionary origins using
genetic7 comparisons. They traced the ancestral lineage of monarchs to a migratory population that likely originated in the southern U.S. or Mexico. The monarch's current worldwide distribution appears to stem from three separate dispersal events -- to Central and South America; across the Atlantic; and across the Pacific. In all three cases, the butterfly independently lost its migratory behavior.
The monarch's North American origin runs counter to a long-standing hypothesis that the butterfly originated from a non-migratory tropical species, which later developed the ability to migrate. While historical records have suggested that the monarch's dispersal across the Pacific and Atlantic occurred in the 1800s, the analysis indicated the monarch actually crossed the oceans thousands of years ago. The authors note that more work needs to be done to
fully13 document the butterfly's evolutionary history.
"In order to clearly resolve the history of monarch butterflies, we still need additional fossil, archaeological and genetic data, as well as more advanced technology, becoming available in the future," said study author Shuai Zhan, PhD, a professor in Shanghai Institutes for Biological Sciences and a former
joint14 postdoctoral fellow at the University of Chicago and the University of Massachusetts Medical School.